The first real comprehensive report into the sustainability of Citizen Media sites delivered some good news for the fledgling industry:
Citizen journalism media and local news websites offering user-generated content influence their communities and are here to stay.
The report “Citizen Media: Fad or the Future of News: The rise and prospects of hyperlocal journalism” relied on indepth interviews with 31 different sites and a 600 question online survey targeted 500 citizen sites - 191 responded though.
I’m slowly getting through the full report, which can be found here. And I’ll blog about my impressions as I do.
It’s a great read if you are interested in the area - but hey, I do run a citizen media site - so my enthusiasm for dissecting the industry could be somewhat biased. But it was really interesting to look at how other sites envision citizen journalism and it is really a diverse area.
Some of the ones that stood out to me are:
ChiTown Daily News High-quality citJ: news, sports, culture, commentary, photos
Baristanet Group blog with citJ and commentary on local news, politics and events, with special focus on food and real estate; plus community discussion forums, polling, photos, mashup maps.
CTNewsJunkie Features original reporting on the state’s political, legal and business universe.
H2O Town Open, independent citJ venue, anyone registered can post. Community news, commentary, resources.
As to the title of my post? Well this is what Jan Schaffer, the report author had to say about citizen journalism sites:
Rather than delivering comprehensive news and “finished stories,” most sites are “forming as fusions of news and schmooze” that pay particular attention to key issues in their communities
And lastly here are is a summary of a few figures from the report, I found on the Editors Weblog:
73%, of the survey respondents, pronounced their sites to be a ‘success,’ based largely on the impact in their communities.
82% said they provided opportunities for dialogue.
61% said they watchdogged local government.
39% said they helped the community solve problems.
27% said they increased voter turnout.
17% said they increased the number of candidates running for office.
The report is generating some good critique of the industry and my friend Jon, pointed me to this one.
Hope to see you round the norg 